Blown Slave Cylinder

Hi Mitchell,

Compare the slave cylinder length in your picture to the length measured from the mounting hole to where the slaves' pushrod would contact the clutch fork inside the transaxle.

The distance measured inside the transaxle should shorter than the bare cylinder by almost the length of the stroke of the pushrod. If that works out ok then either the fork is jammed or the two new slave cylinders are both bad, or something else is going on (throw out bearing stuck?).

If you wanted to check the slave cylinder outside the car to see exactly where its' leaking you would have to compress the pushrod in almost the full stroke, then try bleeding the part. It wont be easy to clamp or retain the pushrod in the retracted position but nothing will be learned by testing it without the pushrod retracted.

The chances of buying two bad slave cylinders is pretty low, however having three cylinders acting the same way would point to something other than the slave cylinders in my mind.

If the fork distance to the mounting hole dimension is the same or greater as your slave cylinder at rest the it's definitely the fork.

It's a great mystery at this point...

Cheers
Ian
Hey Ian,

Thanks for the reply!

I'm assuming by the length question your saying that if its not long enough then it's extending ut not pushing on the clutch fork?

I think it's fine as when I insert the slave into position it has to compress itself so it can slide in far enough so it's definitely moving the piston back into the chamber.

I'm going to send a slave up there with no return spring so hopefully it can leave the piston in the position it is moving to when I install it.

It's hard to tell the condition of the clutch fork as I can't see anything when it's all in but it does look like it's in the correct starting position at least.
 

Ian Clark

Supporter
Hi Mitchell
Sounds like a plan, you will know how much the slave pushrod moved back into it's housing. That length is your available stroke to lift the clutch. Can't wait to hear what you find out.

Cheers
Ian
 
Hi Mitchell
Sounds like a plan, you will know how much the slave pushrod moved back into it's housing. That length is your available stroke to lift the clutch. Can't wait to hear what you find out.

Cheers
Ian
Hey Ian,

So I started some investigating, when I pushed the slave into position it has actually pushed the piston the full length back in the cylinder. Is there supposed to be a gap to allow fluid behind? should I shorten the pushrod? As the fluid comes in from the side, it might be squirting it in around the seal anyway and not pushing it forward to disengage clutch?
 

Ian Clark

Supporter
Hi Mitchell, By what your describing the clutch slave appears to be properly engaged at rest, if there's no fluid leaking anywhere then there must be air in the clutch circuit. That includes the clutch master possibly. I'd much rather have that be the problem than transaxle out to inspect the clutch fork and throwout bearing.

Cheers
Ian
 

Terry Oxandale

Skinny Man
Still trying to understand why hitting the stops, or misalignment causes a leak. Brakes basically hit a solid stop hydraulically, yet the MCs don't leak because of that. Randy's post #7 seems to be "it", unless the design is faulty (which could be being this is the second of two (same design or product) that has leaked.
 

Ian Clark

Supporter
I should add that some clutch master cylinders can be very difficult to bleed by the standard pump the pedal method. Mitchell have you tried vacuum bleeding the clutch circuit? Cheers
 
I should add that some clutch master cylinders can be very difficult to bleed by the standard pump the pedal method. Mitchell have you tried vacuum bleeding the clutch circuit? Cheers
So I habe not tried the vacuum bleeding method but I purchased one a the other day. When I have some time I will try it. So should the piston be moving all the way to the back of the cylinder or should there be a gap between it? I’ve attached a picture of the piston and seal and the view from where the fluid enters the slave. Is the piston too far back in the slave? Is it worth shortening the pushrod to have the Piston further towards the fork and therefore the fluid behind the slave from the start? Or is it in the correct position? I have a new one sitting here but I will be incredibly disapoint should it happen again.
E3995B16-96E8-43A4-BF6B-AB706D13AD2F.jpeg
F689B90D-BD86-4F82-9825-F28056BF6259.jpeg
 
Still trying to understand why hitting the stops, or misalignment causes a leak. Brakes basically hit a solid stop hydraulically, yet the MCs don't leak because of that. Randy's post #7 seems to be "it", unless the design is faulty (which could be being this is the second of two (same design or product) that has leaked.
I thought the same thing. Surely it Would have to have a substantial amount of pressure to blow past a seal. If it has air in the system would that cause fluid to leak out? I just thought it wouldn’t work properly. The issue isn’t that it’s not working, it’s that it is spewin out past the seal.
 

Ian Clark

Supporter
Hi Mitchell,

If there's no visible damage to the seal or piston bore then the slave cylinder should work. If you have three cylinders acting the same way it's hard to point at the slave cylinder being the culprit.

That doesn't explain why or how clutch fluid was getting past the seal and into the dust boot. Does the clutch slave leak fluid past the seal and dust boot when pressurized to normal clutch actuation levels while not mounted in the transaxle? That would test a leak scenario simulating the slave piston is not engaging the clutch fork arm when installed.

If you can generate enough pressure in the system to blow past the seal then there could not be air in the system. How hard to pump was the clutch pedal when there were fluid leaks seen in the dust boot? Was that more or less pedal pressure than you remember when the clutch was working before the slave cylinder swap?

When bleeding the system how much did the fluid level drop in the clutch reservoir? Did the fluid level in the reservoir ever drop out of sight? If it did then air could have been introduced into the clutch circuit.

There is no adjustment in the clutch slave to the transaxle case to the clutch fork to the throwout bearing to the clutch pressure plate fingers. If all those parts are good parts and not operating properly it's an assembly issue or air in the line. It's a head scratcher to analyze remotely for sure...

Cheers
Ian
 

Ian Anderson

Lifetime Supporter
My gut would say that no you should not be able to see the seal when you look down the bleed or fill hole. In my head that would mean that the fluid would have a way past the seal in your picture a little dogleg upwards near the bleed nipple past th e seal and into the dust gator.

Does it have a "rubber cup" missing as seen in this image that will stop the piston so that the seal never moves further than thebore and not into the bleed nipple area?


1637069944387.png
 

Terry Oxandale

Skinny Man
Ian is on the mark here, but the exact positioning of seal is critical in that when you "just see the bottom...". If you can see the pressure flap (the directional, concave portion of the seal or Rubber Cup in the above diagram (the edge of the lip that is facing rearward), it would seem that fluid pressure at that point cannot swell the lip radially outward to seal the cylinder because pressure is applied now to the wrong side of this flap or lip. If the lip (flap) is not visible, and you only can see the base of the seal (NOT the edge of the lip), then you may have a properly positioned piston/seal. Looking at the photo (out of focus, or I need new glasses), it looks too close to call, because it appears you are looking at the base of the seal, but surely the lip is extremely close to the port at that position based on the other photo of the piston only.

If indeed the seal is too far rearward, a shim or some means of forcing the piston just a mm or two, forward should help (the small protrusion at the rear of the piston in the drawing above would be too short). If indeed the seal is too far rearward, that to me indicates a faulty design or machining, and perhaps why you've had two in a row with this problem. If the lip is not positioned, it would allow some amount of fluid (not much) by the seal until the piston moved forward and properly stopped any leakage. Heck, stick a penny in the end of the bore, reassemble, and go with it ;).


I left the lip (cup if you will) in the drawing below "relaxed" so that it better illustrated my point. Normally it would be compressed in the bore.

clutch slave seal.jpg
 
Last edited:
Hi Mitchell,

If there's no visible damage to the seal or piston bore then the slave cylinder should work. If you have three cylinders acting the same way it's hard to point at the slave cylinder being the culprit.

That doesn't explain why or how clutch fluid was getting past the seal and into the dust boot. Does the clutch slave leak fluid past the seal and dust boot when pressurized to normal clutch actuation levels while not mounted in the transaxle?

I have not tried this as such, but once I noticed it was buggered I pulled it out of the car and it would build up a lot more pressure to the point the pedal could not be compressed until bleed opened. (Although a small amount of fluid did leak out still)

That would test a leak scenario simulating the slave piston is not engaging the clutch fork arm when installed.

If you can generate enough pressure in the system to blow past the seal then there could not be air in the system. How hard to pump was the clutch pedal when there were fluid leaks seen in the dust boot?

my wife was doing the pedal work but when leakin the clutch would just keep going to the floor and reservoir would drop.

Was that more or less pedal pressure than you remember when the clutch was working before the slave cylinder swap?

id say more pressure when working

When bleeding the system how much did the fluid level drop in the clutch reservoir? Did the fluid level in the reservoir ever drop out of sight? If it did then air could have been introduced into the clutch circuit.

fluid was in the reservoir the whole timel

There is no adjustment in the clutch slave to the transaxle case to the clutch fork to the throwout bearing to the clutch pressure plate fingers. If all those parts are good parts and not operating properly it's an assembly issue or air in the line. It's a head scratcher to analyze remotely for sure...

Cheers
Ian
 
It
Ian is on the mark here, but the exact positioning of seal is critical in that when you "just see the bottom...". If you can see the pressure flap (the directional, concave portion of the seal or Rubber Cup in the above diagram (the edge of the lip that is facing rearward), it would seem that fluid pressure at that point cannot swell the lip radially outward to seal the cylinder because pressure is applied now to the wrong side of this flap or lip. If the lip (flap) is not visible, and you only can see the base of the seal (NOT the edge of the lip), then you may have a properly positioned piston/seal. Looking at the photo (out of focus, or I need new glasses), it looks too close to call, because it appears you are looking at the base of the seal, but surely the lip is extremely close to the port at that position based on the other photo of the piston only.

If indeed the seal is too far rearward, a shim or some means of forcing the piston just a mm or two, forward should help (the small protrusion at the rear of the piston in the drawing above would be too short). If indeed the seal is too far rearward, that to me indicates a faulty design or machining, and perhaps why you've had two in a row with this problem. If the lip is not positioned, it would allow some amount of fluid (not much) by the seal until the piston moved forward and properly stopped any leakage. Heck, stick a penny in the end of the bore, reassemble, and go with it ;).


I left the lip (cup if you will) in the drawing below "relaxed" so that it better illustrated my point. Normally it would be compressed in the bore.

View attachment 118965
its hard to tell from the small hole. Will get the magnifying glasS on it to see if I can work it out. If I shorten the pushrod then that should allow the piston to sit forward more.
 
My gut would say that no you should not be able to see the seal when you look down the bleed or fill hole. In my head that would mean that the fluid would have a way past the seal in your picture a little dogleg upwards near the bleed nipple past th e seal and into the dust gator.

Does it have a "rubber cup" missing as seen in this image that will stop the piston so that the seal never moves further than thebore and not into the bleed nipple area?


View attachment 118964
It’s similar. The cup is a seal that sits in a groove in the piston. A photo on post #47 shows it’s position. It’s looking like I can see the bottom of the seal but not quite the flap part, but it sure would be close.
 

Terry Oxandale

Skinny Man
Mitch, if you shorten the pushrod, that would help, but what is the clutch wear doing to this relationship? I believe clutch wear will help you out in your case (guessing). In my Porsche set-up, wear would cause the problem to re-emerge as the clutch disc gets thinner. So you may be fine and done, especially if your slave has a spring in the back (behind the piston), because it will always be pushing the piston forward with some light pressure. If it doesn't have a spring...then?

My thoughts about sticking a shim behind the piston prevents the piston from ever being pushed far enough back to ever present this issue. I suppose either option will be effective if this is indeed the problem.
 

Ian Clark

Supporter
Hi Mitch,

I'd really like this not turn into an engine out although you should be able to sneak the transaxle out on it's own.

Probabilities are 1) air in system 2) something wrong between the slave and clutch pressure plate fingers 3) defective clutch slave cylinder.

If each slave was bench tested by holding it in a vise at the fully retracted length it would be east to bleed, pressurize and measure the psi the part can handle without leaking. Then you'll know which or none of the slaves are ok.

If they are ok, we're back to air in the system or a problem with the other clutch actuation parts.

Cheers
Ian
 
Hi Mitch,

I'd really like this not turn into an engine out although you should be able to sneak the transaxle out on it's own.

Probabilities are 1) air in system 2) something wrong between the slave and clutch pressure plate fingers 3) defective clutch slave cylinder.

If each slave was bench tested by holding it in a vise at the fully retracted length it would be east to bleed, pressurize and measure the psi the part can handle without leaking. Then you'll know which or none of the slaves are ok.

If they are ok, we're back to air in the system or a problem with the other clutch actuation parts.

Cheers
Ian
Would I need to have the cylinder fully compressed or could I have it half compressed. That would at least prove the seal. Then to get it in o would have to release fluid but if it fails when it's then installed, it will mean the push rod is Too long. To be honest I may just shorten pushrod anyway.
 

Randy V

Moderator-Admin
Staff member
Admin
Lifetime Supporter
Mitch -
Had this clutch slave been working fine in a driving car up to the point where it sat idle for a very long period of time - and now it has this problem?
 
Would I need to have the cylinder fully compressed or could I have it half compressed. That would at least prove the seal. Then to get it in o would have to release fluid but if it fails when it's then installed, it will mean the push rod is Too long. To be honest I may just shorten pushrod anyway.
Hi ,
on the Renault Alpine with the V6 and un08 box, bleeding the clutch could be hell..... so in the French Alpine world (and also used on Peugeot 504) we bleed completely different , we modifie a bleed nipple to accept a hose, which we connected to the rear left brake caliper, and pumping brake liquid from the brakes through the sleeve cylinder, to master cylinder, to get all the air out..
On the Renault 25 v6 turbo, you had from factory an extension on the bleeder to bring higher up the outlet, in order to fully bleed the sleeve cylinder.
Paul
 
Back
Top