Tim, I am by no means an expert on this, I just went through months trying to get my car to run right. After chasing the carbs and not getting anywhere, I went back to basics. The shop thatI paid to go through the engine from top to bottom, didn't. Among other things, they did not set the valves correctly, they didn't set the timing correctly, and they didn't notice that the dizzy wasn't tracking with the RPMs smoothly. This is a centrifugal advance distributor and the weights were hanging up at 2500 rpm and then jumping. I had to open it up and clean it out and lube it. Anyway, it was only after ruling out what I had previously assumed that I could get to the problem and solve it. Over the months I read tech manuals and talked to engine builders and redline weber. There is a lot of confusing info to be sure.
Performance VW guys use a lot of webers 44 IDF, 48 IDF and 48 IDA mostly. I used some of the tech notes at
www.aircooled.net regarding setting up and troubleshooting webers to best understand the sequence. I know, I know - aircooled? VW?, hey ... webers don't know what engine they are on. HA!
To check my idle circuit I drive steady state at 2000 rpnm or run the engine steady state there and then check plugs. I also have an exhaust gas analyzer that I used. The lean engine pops, sputters and backfires. The rich engine smells it. At steady state main circuit (between 2500 and 4500 - I pick 3500 rpm), how does it sound?
The accelerator pumps work at any crack of throttle, so you have to be careful about not allowing their influence. If the engine bogs and then clears what accelerating, then the pumps could be squirting too much. Surging is usually asssociated with a lean condition.
Did you buy the carbs and bolt them on or did someone dial them in for you? My carbs were problematic out of the box - I couldn't get all barrels to similar setting on the mixture screws. I pulled them and they were all different shapes - I had to get replacements. Of course I also had to reject the carbs for my application idle, main and air correction. I have my jet kit, gauges and reamers if you need to borrow any of that.
What I do know is, when properly dialed in they are sweet.
regards,
Mike