I do not fear them and I do not hate them but i'd like to understand them a bit more.
Keith,
Absolutely, it's just when you do look you find so many contradictions it's hard to know which view is right. I have always said I could not believe any religion that finds murder acceptable.
I am very very lucky. I was bought up in a stable supportive family, I had so much to live for, so I often wonder, what could possibly drive a young man to the point where he felt he had nothing worth living for.
One mans view seems to support the Terry Waite view on what drives terrorists, (don't think he works for the BBC) and a bit long but due to my ignorance I have to assume the quotations from the Quran are correct.
So unless someone can show me those quotes from the Quran are not true, it appears pretty clear cut that murder and killing are not, as in the Christian faith, acceptable in Islam.
Islam Does Not Promise 72 Virgins for Martyrs: an explanation
Many adversaries of Islam and those whom have been deprived of the Truth have wrongly and continuously asserted that Islam or the Quran promises 72 virgins to martyrs. This article is a response to such baseless assertion against the message of Islam.
The incorrect assumption that “Islam promises 72 Virgins for Martyrs in Heaven” unfortunately signifies deep misconceptions in the West with regards to Islam. It is a myth repeated so often that has misled many people in accepting it as truth and an evidence of an obviously insane religion.
It is the myth of the 72 virgins
When news of a suicide bombing appears in the headlines, it is automatically assumed that some crazy Arab or Muslim must have sacrificed his earthly life to have gained the erotic and everlasting pleasure from the company of 72 virgins in paradise.
Many people are surprised when told that Islam does not promise 72 virgins, and actually condemns people who commit suicide. No matter how many times it is repeated through the media, it will not changed the fact that such assertion is an absurd lie.
The “virgin” myth has clearly received more than its fair share of publicity due to its hilarity. The image of a lunatic suicide bomber taking his pick from 72 luscious virgins is much more welcoming to today’s masses and their imagination than whether or not it logically and rationally would suffice. At the very least, it makes for a particularly gratifying affirmation for those who would love to see their political gain protected against Islam and within the Islamic countries.
The harsh punishment promised by God for people who commit suicide or murder could not be any clearer than the following verse of the holy Quran, which holds absolute precedence of authority over any other Islamic scripture:
But let there be amongst you Traffic and trade by mutual good-will: Nor kill (or destroy) yourselves: for verily God hath been to you Most Merciful! If any do that in rancor and injustice, soon shall We cast them into the Fire: And easy this it is for God. – Chapter 4 (Surah An-Nisa): Verse 29 – 30
Moreover, Muslims view suicide as “Major Sin” with severe punishment in the hereafter. This is also re-enforced by several authentic Hadiths, or sayings of the Prophet Muhammad (s.a), such as the followings:
Narrated Jundab the Prophet said, “A man was inflicted with wounds and he committed suicide, and so Allah said: My slave has caused death on himself hurriedly, so I forbid Paradise for him.” (Bukhari Volume 2, Book 23, Number 445)
Narrated Thabit bin Ad-Dahhak:”And if somebody commits suicide with anything in this world, he will be tortured with that very thing on the Day of Resurrection. (Bukhari Volume 8, Book 73, Number 73)
The condemnation of Islam towards suicide is so great that it would be unimaginable to think that sex has been promised for its reward.
Where has the 72 virgin myth come from?
So one might ask where such a myth could have sprung from and why the number “72 virgins”?
It comes from an alleged saying attributed to Prophet Muhammad, which has neither been verified nor authenticated. Muslims refer to these dubious sayings as Gharib Hadiths, which mean sayings of Prophet Muhammad (pbuh) in that they are conveyed by only one narrator.
The dubious hadith of “72 virgins” goes as such:
The Prophet Muhammad was heard as saying: “The smallest reward for the people of Paradise is an abode where there are 80,000 servants and 72 wives, over which stands a dome decorated with pearls, aquamarine, and ruby, as wide as the distance from Al-Jabiyyah (a Damascus suburb) to – Sana’a (Yemen)” – Sunan al-Tirmidhi Hadith 2562
It is interesting to note that majority of the Muslims outside the western world have not even heard of such saying, which ironically makes the west more aware of it than the Muslim world.
Even considering that such saying exists and is valid, there is no mention of virgins or deserving martyrs. This is a weak narration from an untrustworthy source.
Again, it must be stressed upon that the above saying cannot be verified as authentic due to the fact that there is a discrepancy in its “Sanad”, (or chain of transmitters). As such, Muslims are not required to believe in these Hadith for there is a chance that it may have been fabricated or corrupted along the way.
Even so, as dubious as it may be, nowhere does it mention anything about virgins being rewarded to anyone who commit suicide for any reason. What it does mention however are wives, which scholars have argued, should not even be translated literally for it may convey a metaphorical meaning such as companions.
As mentioned earlier, a convincing majority of Muslims do not believe that such Hadith is authentic, but western media have definitely made hay with it.
Today, the myth of the “72 virgins” is amongst other false arguments against Islam, which is brought forth and kept nourished by those, whose arrogance or ignorance motivates them to prevail against Islam and its spirit of Truth. Political and financial entities have used media sources to twist this alleged saying to suit their fancies and smear Islam with ridicule and humiliation.
So, it leads many uninformed individuals to think that when a Palestinian youth is driven to kill him self in order to destroy Israeli soldiers, it is because he wants to indulge himself in endless heavenly erotica. It is never about the mistreatment by the Israelis, demolishing Palestinian homes, killing their women and childern during the bright of the day or their sleep. It is never about blockading of food and life’s essentials by air, land and sea and it is never about the years of anguish and oppression felt but the people of Palestine
Suicide attack is an act of desperation:
Dr. Robert Pape, an American Political Scientist and a professor of University of Chicago in his book, Dying to Win, proves that suicidal killing is a phenomenon of desperation. After studying all recent suicide attacks around the world, he concludes that in every case and without exception, suicide attacks were response to occupation of an ethnic group.
Although the act of committing suicide in order to kill others should be condemned and criticized, it is perhaps more significant and practical to investigate what truly drives such individuals to do it. Human beings with families and claims to their sovereignty do not just kill themselves.
Very often, we fail to see the real reason behind such desperate acts, yet it is easier for us to believe what we are expected to believe and what is easy for us to believe: the myth of the “72 virgins”.
