I would object to the question. I would just be irritated at whomever was inflicting the choice on me. The two cars have nothing in common other than styling, and they exist in the marketplace for entirely different reasons and appeal to different interests.
A more sensible question might be one of (as examples):
- Ford GT vs. Ferrari 430 vs Gallardo
- GT-40 Replica vs. Daytona Coupe Replica vs Cobra Replica
- Superformance vs. ERA vs. RCR
If you don't know immediately which one you prefer (for a given situation), you need to do more needs-analysis and/or you need to research the two vehicles at more than a completely superficial level.