Apologies Rod, no insult intended.
As for walls, they can work but it does matter how much effort you want to put into it. I've spent time patrolling the Czech, East German borders as well as the Korean DMZ and their draconian measures at border enforcement certainly did work but their task was/is to keep politically oppressed people in, not, keep economic refugees out. So to say a wall couldn't impede illegal entry is simply silly. Nothing is 100% foolproof but it isn't a binary choice either. Getting the millions down to thousands or even hundreds would be a favorable outcome.
As for reasonable measures, a study of the experience of Israel West Bank Barrier determined that the barrier together with associated security activities was effective in preventing suicide bombings and other attacks and fatalities with little if any apparent displacement. The study colluded changes in terrorist behavior likely resulted from the construction of the Barrier, not from other external factors or events.
The Situational Prevention of Terrorism: An Evaluation of the Israeli West Bank Barrier | SpringerLink
I've previously provided the experience in San Diego.
But you make my point, the human carnage of truckloads of dying illegals, tons of illicit drugs and human trafficking victims is unacceptable. They are coming in because parts of the border are not adequately enforced. That is current state and the outcome of doing nothing. It is also partially driven by an expectation of amnesty for those who economic refugees and profits by those trafficking. But if one supports the border carnage, then one certainly wouldn't want to do anything about it.
All that said, without e-verify, reasonable visa overstay enforcement and coherent limits on chain migration a wall would merely be a useless symbol.
No insult taken, just wanted to make sure Doug isn't lambasted because I said something.
Israel, North Korea, the Berlin Wall, etc. is not the same as our US Border patrol agents. If we want to have the real threat of shooting and killing people illegally crossing the border, then that will definitely stem the tide of illegal immigration. That's a deterent. Like that North Korean defector recently being shot trying to cross the DMZ. But I can't believe you would suggest that we take a like aggressive approach like the Israelis or North Koreans.
And I thought your point was that a wall will impede or stop illegal immigration, not illegal immigrants dying in trucks? Seriously, a wall can be tunneled under, scaled and climbed over or there are plenty of illegal operations to get illegal immigrants through border crossings.
But again, I'll repeat, I'm not against building the wall. Build a wall! I just want Mexico to pay for it. I don't. And I don't think it will stop illegal immigrants from finding another way. :thumbsup: